Thursday, 31 January 2019

Waterdeep by Troy Denning

(Forgotten Realms #10, The Avatar Trilogy #3)
(First published 1989)

Following the calamitous events in Tantras, during which the gods Bane and Torm perished, the magic-user Midnight and her allies must bring the Tablet of Fate - one of a pair of ancient artifacts upon which the duties of the gods are recorded - to the city of Waterdeep, so that it can be returned to the overgod Ao. However, the god of death, Myrkul, and the god of murder, Bhaal, have other plans - as does Midnight's erstwhile ally Cyric, who covets the Tablets for his own selfish purposes.




The third and final book in the epic, and occasionally epically silly, Avatar Trilogy (later expanded to become a quintet) is somewhat different to the preceding novels. Written by Troy Denning instead of Scott Ciencin, the prose is a marked step up from both Shadowdale and Tantras. Unfortunately, though the writing is superior, the same cannot be said for the delivery of the story or its content.

The first hundred pages or so in particular are a slog. Unlikely events conspire to put artificial obstacles in the way of our heroes making it to Waterdeep. Denning has a habit of glossing over the most interesting developments in the story, only to then go back and explain them after the fact, resulting in the narrative lacking the sense of momentum and adventure that Ciencin's novels, despite their often amateurish writing, managed to convey.

Once again, Cyric is the book's standout character. His battle of wills with his sentient, bloodthirsty sword makes for one of the strongest scenes in the entire trilogy. Compared with the paper-thin characterizations of Midnight and comic-book bad guy Myrkul, Cyric's background and motivations make a lot of sense. Here is a young orphan raised on the streets of one of the evilest cities in the Forgotten Realms, given an opportunity to seize ultimate power and free himself from the machinations of the wizards and gods that are so ubiquitous in every corner of the setting. It's difficult not to root for him in the face of Midnight's constant stupidity and the blatant selfishness and callousness of the gods.

As mentioned, Myrkul - ostensibly the novel's main villain - is a rather hapless villain. It's unclear why the God of Death, whose sphere of influence includes the undead, would make a ragtag group of ambling zombies his tool of choice to thwart the heroes and recover the Tablets - I assume Larloch, Szass Tam, and various other liches, vampire lords, and eminently more intelligent and powerful minions were unavailable - nor is it clear why Midnight, Kelemvor and co actually fear said zombies so much. It is perhaps fitting that Myrkul's final act as a god is a crawl through the filthy sewers of Waterdeep before getting royally pummeled by the heroes.

Thankfully, Bhaal, the God of Murder, makes for a more terrifying threat. The book's standout scene involves Bhaal massacring his way through an entire citadel of defenders, Jason Vorhees-style, while our heroes try desperately to stop him. In the end, it takes a superhuman act of will from Cyric (of all people!) to vanquish the Lord of Murder once and for all.

For a novel named Waterdeep, the titular city makes a disappointingly brief appearance. That said, despite the turgid start and middle of the novel, it does finish strongly once the heroes make it to the City of Splendors. The denouement at the foot of the Celestial Stairway on Mount Waterdeep is as iconic as Mystra's death in the first book in the trilogy, as our heroes (and villains) each get what they deserve. Even Ao, the overgod, who, it turns out, also has to answer to someone - possibly the Abrahamic God, though in greater likelihood the DM.

All in all, Waterdeep is a mediocre conclusion to a trilogy that had its work cut out from the start, carrying as it did the burden of explaining the transition from 1st to 2nd edition D&D on its shoulders, as well as attempting to novelize a series of adventure modules. The somewhat jarring switch in style from the previous two books doesn't do Waterdeep many favours, and neither does the obligation to continue Midnight and Kelemvor's execrable romance and the poorly conceived schemes of the Dark Gods, or the absence of Bane's clowning villainy, which was at least amusing. Nonetheless, older fans of the Reams will still find much to remember fondly. For Realms historians, the trilogy represents a panoramic snap shot of fantasy's most detailed setting three decades ago, before the hundreds of novels and blockbuster video game adaptations that would follow.

*** out of *****

10 comments:

  1. Thank you for your valuable thoughts. You have taught me how to survive the situation by creating a better plan. Visitjogos friv gratis
    Jogos online
    jogos 4 school

    ReplyDelete
  2. One of the most prominent issues the students have to deal with while writing assignments is plagiarism. Hence, they extensively use plagiarism checker to check if there are any copied content in the paper. Choose Myassignmenthelp.com
    Another major reason for using plagiarism checkers is that universities do not accept plagiarized content. Plagiarism is a serious offence. Hence, if found, the students are suspended or might even lose the grades.
    Due to these limitations, it is evident that the plagiarism checking & word counter tool are not at all effective to check plagiarism. The term plagiarism is actually very broad. It is merely not coping with words. But these tools, unfortunately, detect words but not ideas. Hence, the chances of plagiarized papers remain.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thanks for sharing informative stuff on Assignment Help! You have explained all relevant information on writing services in this write-up. Students who are struggling for higher marks can visit greatassignmenthelp to place their order for quick help.
    Assignment Help Online
    Online Assignment Help
    Assignment Help Online Services
    Assignment Helper
    Assignment Assistance
    Assignment Help Experts
    Online Assignment Help Services
    Assignment Writing Help

    ReplyDelete
  4. Use any valid Visa, Mastercard, Diners, and Credit Card, or pay through your Net. You will be taken to page where you can see your current bill online.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Thank you for sharing this! Quicken is used to follow finances and finance related work. It can record and categorize spending, create detailed budgets, and give information about bank and credit card balances. Quicken send reminders when bills are due, either by SMS or e-mail, or through its mobile app. For an extra fee, Quicken offers a service called Quicken Bill Pay, which allows users to pay their bills directly through Quicken. You can done any finance related work with Quicken during work sometime you can face some problem with this app if you face any problem you can call freely in our Quicken support Phone number +1-888-817-0312. Quicken support team is always help you.
    Quicken support
    Quicken Help
    Quicken Customer Support Phone Number
    Quicken Customer Support

    Quicken Online Backup
    Quicken Backup Support
    Quicken Error CC-800
    quicken won't update
    Quicken Error OL-301-A
    quicken error cc-506
    Quicken Password problems
    Quicken one step update not working

    quicken can't open your data file

    ReplyDelete
  6. HP printers top the favorite list of all customers who are on a printer hunt. People from all over the globe favor HP printers more than any other brands due to their elite features. In HP printer there is HP status monitor, you can see printer’s status and also detect errors associated with it efficiently. Recently, the HP printer users reported some errors while using their printer in windows 10 PC. If you come upon such errors, then you need to put a call on HP Tech Support Phone Number and make connection with the technicians. After that, you need to follow their advice to resolve this error. https://www.hpprintersupportpro.com/hp-printer-tech-support

    Hp tech support
    Hp technical support
    hp tech support number
    hp technical support number
    hp tech support phone number
    hp technical support phone number
    hp printer tech support
    hp printer technical support
    hp printer tech support number
    hp printer technical support number
    hp printer tech support phone number
    hp printer technical support phone number

    ReplyDelete
  7. Your Apple mobile device can throw error at all of a sudden too, as after all it’s a machine and it is in the habit of machine to throw errors. If you tired of trying everything that you could, then why don’t you gives
    Apple Mobile Device Service a try. Here, you will get the chance to meet me and know the step-wise solutions to fix your Apple mobile issues. After grabbing my support you will not be disappointed.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Very nice!!! This is really good blog information thanks for sharing. We are a reliable third party QuickBooks Error Code 80029c4a company, offering technical support for various types of technical errors.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Hi, My name is Stefenrobsss , associated with offering best quality support for yahoo email issues. Yahoo mail has immense data and amazing features. With massive attributes comes immense issue too. So, whenever you encounter any glitches regarding Yahoo mail then feel free to call at Yahoo support Phone Number and make connection with me. Here, your entire issues will be eliminated within small interval of time.

    Read more :- Yahoo support

    ReplyDelete
  10. Well-explained blog! Writer has described the complete information of Assignment Help in detailed manner. Find all details regarding expert help at assignmenthelpshop to achieve high marks and to boost your academic performance.
    Assignment Help Online
    Online Assignment Help

    ReplyDelete