Thursday, 31 January 2019

Waterdeep by Troy Denning

(Forgotten Realms #10, The Avatar Trilogy #3)
(First published 1989)

Following the calamitous events in Tantras, during which the gods Bane and Torm perished, the magic-user Midnight and her allies must bring the Tablet of Fate - one of a pair of ancient artifacts upon which the duties of the gods are recorded - to the city of Waterdeep, so that it can be returned to the overgod Ao. However, the god of death, Myrkul, and the god of murder, Bhaal, have other plans - as does Midnight's erstwhile ally Cyric, who covets the Tablets for his own selfish purposes.




The third and final book in the epic, and occasionally epically silly, Avatar Trilogy (later expanded to become a quintet) is somewhat different to the preceding novels. Written by Troy Denning instead of Scott Ciencin, the prose is a marked step up from both Shadowdale and Tantras. Unfortunately, though the writing is superior, the same cannot be said for the delivery of the story or its content.

The first hundred pages or so in particular are a slog. Unlikely events conspire to put artificial obstacles in the way of our heroes making it to Waterdeep. Denning has a habit of glossing over the most interesting developments in the story, only to then go back and explain them after the fact, resulting in the narrative lacking the sense of momentum and adventure that Ciencin's novels, despite their often amateurish writing, managed to convey.

Once again, Cyric is the book's standout character. His battle of wills with his sentient, bloodthirsty sword makes for one of the strongest scenes in the entire trilogy. Compared with the paper-thin characterizations of Midnight and comic-book bad guy Myrkul, Cyric's background and motivations make a lot of sense. Here is a young orphan raised on the streets of one of the evilest cities in the Forgotten Realms, given an opportunity to seize ultimate power and free himself from the machinations of the wizards and gods that are so ubiquitous in every corner of the setting. It's difficult not to root for him in the face of Midnight's constant stupidity and the blatant selfishness and callousness of the gods.

As mentioned, Myrkul - ostensibly the novel's main villain - is a rather hapless villain. It's unclear why the God of Death, whose sphere of influence includes the undead, would make a ragtag group of ambling zombies his tool of choice to thwart the heroes and recover the Tablets - I assume Larloch, Szass Tam, and various other liches, vampire lords, and eminently more intelligent and powerful minions were unavailable - nor is it clear why Midnight, Kelemvor and co actually fear said zombies so much. It is perhaps fitting that Myrkul's final act as a god is a crawl through the filthy sewers of Waterdeep before getting royally pummeled by the heroes.

Thankfully, Bhaal, the God of Murder, makes for a more terrifying threat. The book's standout scene involves Bhaal massacring his way through an entire citadel of defenders, Jason Vorhees-style, while our heroes try desperately to stop him. In the end, it takes a superhuman act of will from Cyric (of all people!) to vanquish the Lord of Murder once and for all.

For a novel named Waterdeep, the titular city makes a disappointingly brief appearance. That said, despite the turgid start and middle of the novel, it does finish strongly once the heroes make it to the City of Splendors. The denouement at the foot of the Celestial Stairway on Mount Waterdeep is as iconic as Mystra's death in the first book in the trilogy, as our heroes (and villains) each get what they deserve. Even Ao, the overgod, who, it turns out, also has to answer to someone - possibly the Abrahamic God, though in greater likelihood the DM.

All in all, Waterdeep is a mediocre conclusion to a trilogy that had its work cut out from the start, carrying as it did the burden of explaining the transition from 1st to 2nd edition D&D on its shoulders, as well as attempting to novelize a series of adventure modules. The somewhat jarring switch in style from the previous two books doesn't do Waterdeep many favours, and neither does the obligation to continue Midnight and Kelemvor's execrable romance and the poorly conceived schemes of the Dark Gods, or the absence of Bane's clowning villainy, which was at least amusing. Nonetheless, older fans of the Reams will still find much to remember fondly. For Realms historians, the trilogy represents a panoramic snap shot of fantasy's most detailed setting three decades ago, before the hundreds of novels and blockbuster video game adaptations that would follow.

*** out of *****

16 comments:

  1. My friend promised to buy me a cup of coffee for referring him to your site. Thank you for coffee. Kindly keep updating us on new articles. Looking for water heaters reviews, best brands, and models? then you have landed at the right place. Heating water has its struggles especially if you are using the wrong heaters. Visit Best Electric Tank Water Heater for more.

    ReplyDelete
  2. HP Printer Offline issue is a very common issue HP users have to face once in a while. When it appears, users with good technical powers can easily cope with the issue while some of them may not be so fluent in patching up technical wounds of HP Printers. In this case, you can seek technical support from Customer Care representatives of HP. They are available 24*7 for the convenience of customers. They have incredible skills in fixing issues related to HP Printer offline likeHP Printer won't Print many more.

    ReplyDelete
  3. For new hp printer need a setup steps to work it smoothly visit 123.hp.com/setup website to complete the setup process.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thank you for bringing to a halt my long search topic. I really benefited from your content. If you are experiencing trouble striking a balance between your busy academic life and handling your online classes, you can get help from a professional who will take online classes on your behalf. It doesn’t matter the kind of help you need, whether it is passing your exam, finishing your assignments or even the entire classwork, you can get help here at Online Class Help .

    ReplyDelete
  5. This is Carol Wood from Australia. She is an expert writer in the domain of custom assignment writing services and working for assignment help. All students are getting high-grade coursework papers at the lowest price and achieving success. His aim is to satisfy a student's paper writing requirement and supplies before the deadline. Read more: environmental assignment help

    ReplyDelete
  6. If you are using QuickBooks payroll to run the business smoothly, this tool is very helpful to manage the business accounting and payroll in one location. If you have any issues related to QuickBooks payroll software, you can call online QuickBooks professionals to get full guidance for solving the errors in the right ways. We work independently as a third-party QuickBooks Support Company and delivering the top-quality QuickBooks payroll support services for QuickBooks payroll users. Our QuickBooks support team is always ready to help you for any type of issues associated to QuickBooks payroll software.
    quickbooks update error 15215
    quickbooks update error 15270
    QuickBooks Error 6000

    ReplyDelete
  7. Nice article. In order for one to graduate with a doctorate degree in nursing practice he/she must complete a capstone project. Notably, A DNP capstone is a scholarly project that demonstrates that a give student has mastered nursing specialty. Specifically, when writing a DNP capstone project, you are expected to synthesize the knowledge that has been learnt in this program and utilize conventional methods in solving a concrete nursing problem. Visit on DNP Capstone Writers for more

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hello there, great stuff you’ve shared here I will be checking regularly for more articles. But wait! When it becomes hard to manage your online assignment, availing Online Assignment Help is the best choice. Many students often fail to submit their assignment before deadlines and end up scoring low grades because they didn’t have enough time to write the assignment given on time and satisfactorily. Visit Assignment Help . for assistance.

    ReplyDelete
  9. assignment help provides needed assistance to all students who require reliable assistance in composing their academic papers For UK Universities. For more explanation, visit the service provider website and quote your order as soon as possible.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Thanks for sharing this post, We are the best independent technical support provider, providing online technical support services including live phone and chat support services for Epson printer users. If you are encountering by epson printer not printing error, I and my printer technicians are technically known for resolving this technical glitch efficiently. Our printer techies are very experienced to resolve it instantly.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Thanks for sharing this post, We are a well-known third-party support service provider, having many years of experience and proficiency for resolving all common issues associated to brother printer. If you don’t have ideas for brother printer scan to PC not working error, our printer technicians are technically experienced for resolving this technical glitch. Our techies are available round the clock to provide quick support or quality assistance.


    Brother printer in error state

    brother printer not recognizing new toner cartridge


    error code 2147500037


    brother hl-2270dw toner reset

    brother printer 0b error

    brother printer troubleshooting

    Brother printer default password

    ReplyDelete
  12. Hallo, teman-teman semua nya kami dari agen indowins ingin menawarkan berbagai jenis permainan dan bonus. whatshapp : +85587536868

    http://ref.mov168.xyz/index.php?slug=GTjuD&C

    ReplyDelete
  13. Connect with professional academic writers via Assignment Help in Ireland to finish your papers without any issue. So, buy Online Assignment Help and complete your homework before the due dates.
    Visit us : Assignment Help Online

    ReplyDelete
  14. Did you successfully complete the AOL Gold Download process? In case not, do not hesitate as the technical team is available to help you. Try to contact the experts and convey them to the existing issue. Professionals are well-versed and can rectify the problem instantly. Provide them the proper details that they require and get your issue solved. The availability is all round the clock, 24*7.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Take assignment help when you want to get subject matter experts' assistance in the UK. Establish a strong connection with your service provider and share your queries or requirements with them if you don't want to lose your money.

    ReplyDelete